Hesham Khalafallah
  1. Home
  2. Knowledge
  3. What Holds Us Back?

What Holds Us Back?

Hesham KhalafallahHesham Khalafallah5 min readARENFR
Cover of part three of the Growing Together series, titled What Holds Us Back?

In the first article, we saw that philosophy, faith and history agree: integration is the law of success. In the second, I described what I have seen myself: companies in our region working like isolated islands, a scattered market without shape, compared with clusters in China and India that compete and cooperate at the same time.

The question remains: why? Why do we know the value of working together, yet fail to practise it?

I believe the problem does not lie in individuals alone, but in deeper roots spread across three levels: the structure we work within, the mindset we think with, and the education that prepared us for all of it.

1. Structure: we consume technology rather than produce it

Today, technology is created and launched in China, America, Europe, Korea or India. We usually know nothing about it while it is still an idea in development. Then, after a short or long while, it reaches us as a finished product, a service or a technology. We discover it, learn it, and begin to understand how to use it.

In my experience, many global technology companies present in our region operate here as branches for operations, management and follow-up, not as centres for manufacturing and development. As a result, deep knowledge, the know-how, does not transfer to us. We know how to use, but not how what we use was made.

That is why our successes often remain limited. We frequently celebrate them as if they were inventions, when in fact they are developments or applications of technology made by others. This does not diminish the effort of those behind them, but it reminds us of the distance still ahead.

Ibn Khaldun described this condition more than six centuries ago. In his Muqaddimah, he devoted a chapter to the idea that:

The vanquished always love to imitate the victor.

— Ibn Khaldun, The Muqaddimah

He explained that the soul “believes perfection lies in whoever has overcome it.” He was speaking of nations in war and politics, but the idea applies to technology today:

Those who do not produce settle for imitating those who do.

Our history was not always like this. In Abbasid Baghdad, the House of Wisdom was a centre of knowledge production that reached its peak under Caliph al-Ma’mun in the 9th century. Scholars and translators of different backgrounds and faiths worked there together, bringing in the sciences of Greece, Persia and India, then adding to and developing them. The House of Wisdom was not the work of one person; it was an entire civilisational team.

2. Mindset: four reasons we choose isolation

1. Fear for the idea

“We have our own secrets and our own programmes.” I have heard this many times when proposing cooperation. Yet an idea alone has limited value; real value lies in execution. And in technology, execution always needs partners, because no one has every skill alone.

2. A crisis of trust, and the prisoner’s dilemma

In 1950, two researchers at the RAND Corporation in the United States, Merrill Flood and Melvin Dresher, devised a mathematical puzzle that became one of the best-known models in game theory, later known as the “prisoner’s dilemma.”

The idea is simple: two partners in the same situation, neither trusting the other. If they cooperate, both gain. But each fears cooperating and being let down, so each chooses their own separate interest. The result is that both lose, even though cooperation would have made both better off.

This is exactly what happens between many of our companies: fear of the other drives each party to work alone, and everyone loses.

3. The absence of a contract culture

Many partnerships in our region begin with courtesy and kind words, without a clear written agreement, and end in a dispute that stops the partners from ever trying again.

The Qur’an set out the rule more than fourteen centuries ago, in its longest verse:

O you who believe, when you contract a debt for a fixed term, write it down.

— Al-Baqarah 2:282

A clear contract is not a sign of doubt in one’s partner; it is what protects trust between partners and preserves the rights of each.

4. The “small cake” mindset

Many treat the market like a limited cake: if someone else takes a piece, my share shrinks. Economists call this a “zero-sum game”, where one side’s gain equals the other’s loss. A real market, however, is a “positive-sum game”, where everyone’s share grows when they work together to expand it.

3. Education: where the story begins

1. A gap that has never closed

For many years, we have talked about the gap between education and the needs of the labour market, and we are still talking about it today. The problem is greater in technology, because it changes every day while curricula change very slowly. There is often no clear vision linking what students learn to what the market will need tomorrow.

2. Assessment that feeds the ego

Our education system is based mostly on individual assessment. From an early age, students compete for first place and are rewarded for excelling alone. They rarely learn how to succeed as a team, or how a classmate’s success can be part of their own.

Even graduation projects, meant to train students in teamwork, are often carried by a single student while the rest of the team shows little interest. That student graduates convinced they can do everything alone and need no one.

3. Incubators that develop everything… except integration

Even business incubators, meant to build the entrepreneurs of the future, focus on developing many skills: management, marketing, finance and pitching to investors. Yet they rarely address integration. In fact, many are built around competitions between projects, so young founders learn that the person next to them is a competitor, not a potential partner.

Here we recall the Prophet’s ﷺ advice:

Do not hate one another, do not envy one another, do not turn your backs on one another, and be, O servants of God, brothers.

— Narrated by Al-Bukhari and Muslim

Fair competition is welcome, but when it turns into envy and estrangement, everyone loses.

From diagnosis to remedy

If the causes lie in structure, mindset and education, the remedy must also start at these three levels. The good news is that every one of these causes can be addressed, and that our heritage and the experience of others show us the way.

That is the subject of the final article in this series: practical steps any company, institution or university can take to move from isolated islands to a building we construct together.

Hesham Khalafallah

Hesham Khalafallah

International consultant in AI, extended reality and education, and founder of MetaLife Metaverse. He writes about how human learning evolves and the future of education.

Was this article useful?

Questions & discussion

Have a question about the article or an experience to share? Write it here and I will reply within 24 hours.

Your comment is published immediately. Offensive or promotional comments are removed.
  1. Be the first to ask about this article.

Follow only what interests you

Choose what you want to be notified about.