More than 2,300 years ago, the Greek philosopher Aristotle compared a person who lives alone to an isolated piece on a game board: present, yet without a role or an effect. He was not speaking about companies, but he described their situation precisely.
In this series, I raise a question that has occupied me for years: why do companies succeed when they complement one another, and struggle when each works alone? Before we turn to today’s reality, let us start with the foundation: what have philosophy, sociology, faith and history said about working together?
1. Philosophy: no one is complete alone
In his Politics, Aristotle stated that man is “by nature a political animal”, a being made to live in a community. He argued that the isolated individual is not self-sufficient; he is a part that is only complete within the whole.
The idea goes deeper than simply living among others. For Aristotle, people reach their best only within an organised community. Carried into the business world, this means a company cannot reach its full potential in isolation, however strong it may be.
2. Society: Ibn Khaldun and the loaf of bread
The 14th-century Arab scholar Ibn Khaldun took up the same idea in his Muqaddimah, in a phrase that became famous: “Man is social by nature.” He explained it with a simple example: the bread a person eats every day reaches him only through the work of many hands, from farming to milling to baking. No one can secure his food alone.
On this basis, Ibn Khaldun built his theory of asabiyyah, the bond that unites people and joins their efforts. States, in his view, rise when this bond is strong and weaken when it weakens. Among the causes of its decline, he pointed to the wish to “monopolise glory”, when one party wants all credit for success for itself.
When everyone wants the glory for themselves, everyone loses.
3. Faith: cooperation is a command, and discord is a loss
The Qur’an gives a clear command to cooperate:
Cooperate in righteousness and piety, and do not cooperate in sin and aggression.
— Al-Ma’idah 5:2
It also warns of the result of discord:
Do not dispute with one another, lest you lose courage and your strength departs.
— Al-Anfal 8:46
The verse does not say discord merely weakens; it says it leads to failure and the loss of strength. This is an accurate description of what unproductive rivalry does between parties who could have been partners.
The Prophet’s tradition offers a vivid image of integration. The Prophet Muhammad ﷺ said:
The believer to the believer is like a building, each part strengthening the other.
— Narrated by Al-Bukhari and Muslim
And he interlaced his fingers. What stands out is that interlaced fingers are not identical; they differ in length and position, yet together they become stronger. Integration does not mean being identical copies. It means each party completes what the other lacks.
Islam did not stop at calling for cooperation; it gave it clear contracts. Classical jurists set out several forms of partnership, the best known being:
• Sharikat al-‘inan: two or more partners contribute capital and work, and share the profit as they agree.
• Mudarabah: one party provides the capital, the other provides expertise and work, and the profit is shared by agreement.
In other words, partnership in this heritage was not just good intention. It was a system with rules that protected the rights of every party.
4. History: the Medina brotherhood, an early model of integration
When the emigrants from Mecca reached Medina, they had left their wealth and trade behind. The people of Medina, the Ansar, were people of land and farming. The Prophet ﷺ paired the two groups in brotherhood, so that each emigrant became the brother of a man from Medina.
One of the best-known stories of this brotherhood, recorded by Al-Bukhari, is that of Abd al-Rahman ibn Awf and Sa’d ibn al-Rabi’. Sa’d offered to share his wealth with his new brother. Abd al-Rahman thanked him, prayed for blessing on his family and wealth, and said: “Show me the way to the market.” He went to the market, began trading, and soon earned from his own work.
This story holds two lessons for any partnership:
1. The stronger party extends a hand without seeing the other as a rival.
2. The other party keeps its dignity and contributes what it has: expertise and effort.
True partnership is not one side taking from the other. It is each side placing what it owns in one shared place.
5. Lessons from nations… and from companies
History offers two opposite pictures: small nations that grew when they united, and strong nations that weakened when they split. Modern companies then show that the same rule governs business.
Nations that grew through union
• The United Arab Emirates: On 2 December 1971, six emirates proclaimed their union; Ras Al Khaimah joined in February 1972, completing the federation of seven. Small, scattered emirates chose to combine their strength and became a state with a global economic and political presence. It is a contemporary Arab example that integration is possible in our region.
• The Hanseatic League: In 1241, the trading cities of Lübeck and Hamburg in northern Germany formed an alliance, and other cities later joined. The alliance grew into a network of cities and merchant guilds that dominated trade in the Baltic and North Seas for about three centuries. No single city could have done this alone.
• The European Union: After two world wars had devastated Europe, six countries signed the Treaty of Paris on 18 April 1951, creating the European Coal and Steel Community. It began as a partnership in just two industries and became the foundation of the European Union. The irony is that former enemies turned the very industries that had fed the war into a field of cooperation.
Nations that weakened through division
• The Taifa kings of Al-Andalus: After the Umayyad Caliphate of Córdoba collapsed in the early 11th century, Al-Andalus split into some twenty small states. Each declared its independence, and rivalry and conflict were all that bound it to its neighbours. Some even paid tribute to King Alfonso VI of Castile and sought his help against their own brothers. In 1085, Toledo fell without real help from its neighbours. It is a living image of the Qur’anic warning: “Do not dispute with one another, lest you lose courage and your strength departs.”
• The ancient Greek city-states: When the Greek cities united against the Persian invasion, they won at Salamis (480 BC) and Plataea (479 BC). Later they turned on each other, and Athens and Sparta exhausted one another in the Peloponnesian War (431–404 BC). When Philip II of Macedon arrived, he found worn-out cities and defeated them at Chaeronea in 338 BC, ending the era of independent Greek city-states. The same cities won when united and lost their independence when divided.
Companies that succeeded through integration
• Airbus: On 18 December 1970, Airbus was founded as a consortium of French and German aircraft companies, later joined by companies from Spain and Britain. The goal was for European industry to compete with the major American manufacturers rather than with itself. Today Airbus is one of the largest aircraft manufacturers in the world.
• Samsung and Sony: In 2004, these two fierce rivals in consumer electronics created a joint company, S-LCD, to manufacture television panels. They shared the cost of the factory while continuing to compete in selling their own products. This is the essence of “co-opetition”: cooperate where it serves both, compete where each stands apart.
• Star Alliance: On 14 May 1997, five airlines from three continents created an alliance that lets travellers move across their networks as if they were one. EgyptAir is among its members today.
What stands out in all these examples is that no one gave up their identity. Each emirate kept its history, Airbus partners kept their commercial independence, and Samsung and Sony kept competing. Integration does not erase identity; it adds a strength no one could have alone.
What unites these dimensions?
The Greek philosopher, the Arab historian, the religious text and the historical experience all reach the same conclusion: people do not succeed alone, communities grow strong only through integration, and discord leads to failure.
If this is what our heritage, and humanity’s, tells us, why do many companies in our region today still prefer to work alone?
That is the question of the next article, where I move from theory to reality and share what I have observed in my own work between the Arab region and other markets.



